Key Takeaways

  • Type 1 coordination (IEC 60947-4-1): after a short circuit the contactor/overload may be damaged and must be replaced — but must not create a hazard (no explosion, no fire, no molten ejection).
  • Type 2 coordination: after the same fault, the contactor and overload are not damaged and can resume service without replacement — no contact welding.
  • Contact welding happens when fault current sustains the arc across the opening contacts; correct coordination prevents it.
  • Use a properly coordinated motor protective circuit breaker (MPCB) or correctly fused/contactor + overload combination per the manufacturer’s coordination table.

Published by the Korlen Engineering Team · Motor Protection · 9 min read

Category: Motor Control

What Type 1 and Type 2 Coordination Mean

Coordination (often called “type of coordination” in IEC 60947-4-1) describes what happens to the motor starter — contactor and overload relay — after it successfully clears a short circuit. The starter did its job and tripped; the question is whether it survives.

Type 1: the protective device clears the fault and no danger results (no explosion, fire, or ejection of parts). But the contactor and/or overload relay may be damaged and must be replaced before restarting.

Type 2: the fault is cleared and the contactor and overload relay are not damaged — they can be reset and put back into service with no replacement. Contacts must not weld.

Why Contactor Contacts Weld Under a Short Circuit

A contactor’s power contacts are mechanically opened by the trip, but a short-circuit current can be thousands of amps. If the arc is not quenched fast enough, the intense heat welds the silver-alloy contacts together. The motor then cannot be disconnected electrically — a latent hazard.

Welding is driven by two things: (1) the let-through energy the contactor sees, and (2) how quickly the upstream protective device cuts current. A coordinated design limits the energy reaching the contactor so the arc self-extinguishes before welding. That is the entire point of type 2 coordination.

Type 1 vs Type 2 Coordination: Comparison

Criterion Type 1 Type 2
Contact welding Possible Must not occur
Equipment after fault May need replacement Reusable, no replacement
Hazard during fault None (no explosion/fire) None
Downtime Higher (replace parts) Lower (reset & run)
Typical use Non-critical / cost-led Process / continuous duty

How to Achieve Type 2 Coordination

  1. Use a coordinated MPCB. A motor protective circuit breaker is pre-tested by the maker to give type 2 with its contactor at defined ratings — the simplest route.
  2. Or follow the coordination table. If using a separate fuse/contactor/overload, take the exact combination and ratings from the manufacturer’s published type-2 table — do not mix brands or ratings informally.
  3. Match the overload relay. The thermal/magnetic overload must be the type the table specifies; a wrong relay can weld even with the right contactor.
  4. Respect the short-circuit rating. The combination is only type 2 up to the declared prospective short-circuit current. Above it, all bets are off.

Common Mistakes

  • Swapping in a “similar” contactor that is not on the type-2 list — welding returns.
  • Assuming type 1 is “good enough” on a continuous-process line where 30 minutes of downtime costs more than the part.
  • Forgetting the overload relay in the coordination — it carries the same fault.

Korlen Motor Control Range

Korlen’s AC contactors and thermal overload relays are engineered as a coordinated motor-control family — pair them per the coordination table for type 2 performance.


Korlen KNC8 AC contactor

Korlen KNC8 — AC contactor for motor control


Korlen KNR1 thermal overload relay

Korlen KNR1 — thermal overload relay for coordinated motor protection

Model Role Link
KNC8 AC contactor View
KNR1 Thermal overload relay View
KNS12 Manual motor starter View

FAQ

Is Type 2 always required?

No. Type 1 is acceptable where brief downtime and part replacement are tolerable and cost is the priority. Type 2 is preferred for continuous-process and critical-duty motors. See Korlen contactors.

Does Type 2 mean the contactor never wears?

No — it means no damage from the short-circuit event itself. Normal electrical wear from millions of operations still occurs; coordination only governs the fault case.

Can I mix a Korlen contactor with another brand’s relay?

Only if the combination is on a verified type-2 table. Informal mixing risks contact welding. Use matched Korlen KNC8 + KNR1 for assured coordination.

What is an MPCB and does it help?

A motor protective circuit breaker integrates short-circuit and overload protection and is pre-coordinated with a contactor — the fastest path to type 2. Korlen’s manual motor starter KNS12 is a self-contained option.

How do I read a coordination table?

Find your motor FLC and prospective fault current, then read the approved contactor + overload + fuse/breaker combination. Stay within the stated short-circuit limit.

Conclusion

Type 1 vs Type 2 is a downtime-and-safety decision, not a checkbox. If a welded contactor would halt your line, specify type 2 with a verified, matched motor-control combination — and keep the coordination table on file.

Related Resources

Need a type-2 motor coordination table?

Korlen supplies matched contactor + overload relay combinations and the coordination data for your motor rating.

Contact the Korlen Engineering Team

© Korlen Electric. For B2B specification reference. Verify type 1/type 2 coordination against the latest IEC 60947-4-1 table and manufacturer data.